Chocolate turtles, homemade fudge, artisan chocolates, taffy, and ice cream — crafted on Stillwater's historic Main Street.
Every piece in the case is handmade right here in the shop. The red label is our sign — it means this turtle, this cluster, this fudge was crafted from scratch, not shipped in.
Plus chocolates, taffy, and ice cream — a full candy-shop case, made to order the old way.
Made here, since 1995
Barbara Ann's has been making chocolates the same way since 1995 — by hand, in the shop, on Stillwater's Main Street. Thirty years of turtles, fudge, and clusters made the way candy was always supposed to be made.
What you see in the case is what was made here this week. That's what the red label means.
See the Shop
A peek inside the case — exactly what you'll find when you visit.
We looked at every candy shop in Stillwater and ended up coming back to Barbara Ann's because it looked the most delicious.
— Yelp review, May 2026
Visitors regularly describe the turtles and fudge as a reason to come back — and mention the warm, personal feel of the shop.
From our Google reviews
Open Wednesday through Sunday
Call ahead to confirm seasonal hours